Graeme is obviously a newbie/amateur when it comes to sound. No disrespect intended to Graeme, we all have to start somewhere.
Georgia on the other hand is a member of the MPSE (Motion Picture Sound Editors) guild and of the CAS (cinema Audio Society), these aren't organisations you pay to join, you must be invited and nominated. This means that not only must Georgia have been a respected audio post professional for a minimum of 5 years but she has also been judged by a panel of world class audio post professionals to have made "an outstanding contribution to his or her field of endeavor"!
Ironic you should describe Georgia as arrogant while at the same time putting your opinion (as someone with no professional audio experience) against my professional opinion, Georgia's opinion and by implication, that of a number of the world's top audio post professionals! If you honestly believe a beginner is creating better sound than such an internationally recognised and respected professional then yes, I question both your opinion and your judgement and IMHO, feel that maybe you should also.
IndieTalk is lucky to have someone of Georgia's knowledge, experience and professional reputation providing advice and even samples of her work. To be honest, I'm deeply shocked that not one of the recent posters to this thread seems able to tell the difference between very poor sound and good sound or recognise the difference between a beginner and a top professional.